Purpose of Criminal Law
Crime, as the saying goes, does not pay. Criminal law is the body of regulations
that are designed to facilitate social order in a given society, and if any member within that society transgresses
the law they have a civic responsibility to own up to the consequences of their unlawful action. The aim of this
judicial process is to administer what is called "retributive justice" and/or "compensatory justice" through the
execution of what is known as criminal law. But what is the purpose of
criminal law?
Retributive justice and compensatory justice are the means by which the government carries out
criminal punishment for social crimes. Concepts such as "retribution," "just compensation" and "criminal
punishment" within the context ofwhat the purpose of criminal law
is tend to be problematic and even controversial when actual cases are evaluated
by the proper judicial body (from the local district court up to the apex of the court system which is the supreme
court) and the appropriate criminal sanctions are deliberated over and dispensed. Is life imprisonment
(or reclusion perpetua) for
example, a just form of punishment for a crime such as murder or is it capital punishment? If an "eye" is given in
place of an "eye" that has been taken (or a "tooth" for another for that same matter), Mahatma Gandhi cautions us
that everyone in society might just end up blind (or toothless).
This is
the main reason why it is imperative to clarify, express in clear and distinct terms, and keep in
mindwhat the purpose of criminal law is to prevent prejudice affecting a
judicial ruling or verdict carried out by the judicial agency designated to apply the appropriate form of criminal
sanction (e.g. incarceration, probation, fines etc.) to specific criminal cases. The fundamental aims of criminal
justice are correction (thus a prison is technically referred to as a "correctional facility") and deterrence. When
a member in society defies the law they essentially victimize the rest of its members. It’s not uncommon to hear
statements in court room dramas seen on TV that go by the line "The People versus [name of the defendant]." No one,
in addition, is above the law. Lady Justice, the iconic statue representing the principle of justice, for instance,
is seen carrying scales and wearing a blindfold over her eyes.
Many are against the idea that criminal punishment is purely for the purpose of retaliation
to a wrong doer. This scenario, according to critics, runs the risk of being no different from vengeful
action that are common in cases of vendettas or ordinary citizens (so-called "vigilantes") taking the law in
their own hands, so to speak, to "right a wrong." The objective of criminal sanction in the case of
imprisonment, for example, may include rehabilitation and deterrence as much as the aim to retribute. This
provides a utilitarian justification for criminal punishment that both prevents other members in society from
committing/replicating crimes punishable by law and criminals from repeating their unlawful actions, apart
from possibly rehabilitating prisoners that have a light prison sentence (reclusion temporal) and eventually releasing them
back into mainstream society as law-abiding citizens once again. Utilitarianism, after all, is the doctrine
that promotes "the greatest happiness of the greatest number of people."
Last Modified: 08 April 2011
|